ART. III.—Ssŭma Ch‘ien's Historical Records. By HERBERT J. ALLEN, M.R.A.S.
(Continued from page 295 Vol. for 1894.)
CHAPTER II.—The Hsia Dynasty.
Yü of Hsia "was styled Wênming." Yü started from Ch‘ichow. The empire then being at peace and well governed, Kaoyao was made chief minister of state with a view to his ruling the people. The emperor Shun gave audience to Yü, Poyi, and Kaoyao, who addressed each other before the Emperor. The whole nation upon this applauded Yü's brilliant musical performance, and the divine lord of hills and streams, Ch‘i then succeeded to the Imperial throne, and became Emperor Ch‘i, the Prince of Hsia. The Prince of Hsia, Emperor Ch‘i, was the son of Yü, his mother being the daughter of the lord of T‘ushan. As the lord of Hu would not submit, Ch‘i attacked him, and Just before the engagement the "speech at Kan" was delivered to the "six generals, who were summoned together; Ch‘i said, 'Ah! ye who are engaged in my six armies, I have a solemn announcement to make to you. The chief of Hu violently sets at naught the five human relations, and idly casts aside the three obligations of duty. Heaven will on this account oppose him and cut off the span of his life, and I am now but reverently executing the punishment appointed by Heaven. If you on the left do not do your work on the left, and you on the right do not do your work on the right, it will be a disregard of my orders. If you, charioteers, do not observe the rules for the management of your horses, it will be a disregard of my orders. You who obey my orders shall be rewarded in the ancestral temple, but you who disobey my orders shall be slain before the altar of the spirits of the land, and I will destroy both you and your children." He thereupon destroyed the chief of Hu, and the whole nation went to the court of the Prince of Hsia. Emperor Ch‘i died, and his son Emperor T‘aik‘ang (K‘ang the 1st) came to the throne. The Emperor K‘ang the 2nd died, and his son Emperor Hsiang came to the throne. Emperor Hsiang died, and his Son K‘ang the 3rd came to the throne. Emperor K‘ang the 3rd died, and his son Emperor Chu came to the throne. Emperor Chu died, and his son Emperor Huai came the throne. Emperor Huai died, and his Son Emperor Mang came to the throne. Emperor Mang died, and his Son Emperor Hsieh came to the throne. Emperor Hsieh died, and his son Emperor Puhsiang came to the throne. Emperor Puhsiang died, and his brother Emperor Chiung came to the throne. Emperor Chiung died, and his Son Emperor Chin came to the throne. Emperor Chin died, and Emperor Puhsiang's son K‘ungchia, that is Emperor K‘ungchia, came to the throne. Emperor K‘ungchia was fond of enquiring into spiritual matters, and indulged in dissipation, and the virtue of the princes of Hsia having degenerated, the chiefs rebelled. Heaven sent down two dragons, a male and a female. K‘ungchia could not feed them, and could not obtain a dragon-keeper. After the decline of T‘aot‘ang (Yao) one of his descendants, Liu lei, learnt to train dragons, and he was chosen out of the dragon-keepers to wait on K‘ungchia, who gave him the title of dragon-tamer, which was inherited by the descendants of the Shiwei. K‘ungchia died, and his son Emperor Kao came to the throne. Emperor Kao died, and his son Emperor Fa came to the throne. Emperor Fa died, and his son Emperor Li Kuei, Reign of the Emperor Chieh. Ever since the time of K‘ungchia the barons had frequently rebelled. Chieh of Hsia did not strive after virtue, and the wars injured the people. Unable to endure their wrongs they summoned T‘ang to their aid, but he was imprisoned in the tower of Hsia; being afterwards released. T‘ang cultivated virtue, and the princes all went over to him, so T‘ang led an army to attack Chieh of Hsia. Chieh fled to Mingt‘iao, and was eventually driven out and slain. Chieh observed to someone, 'I regret that I did not take the opportunity of killing T‘ang in the tower of Hsia, and then I should not have been brought to such a pass.' T‘ang, being seated on the Imperial throne, superseded Hsia, and gave audience to the people. T‘ang enfeoffed the descendants of the Hsias. Until the time of the Chow dynasty they held the principality of Chi. (To be continued.) 1 Wênming means literally 'accomplishments and orders.' In the 'Counsels of the Great Yü' (L. C. III. p. 52) the Emperor Yü is so named. That chapter of the Book of History is not further referred to by our historian; but we have all the other books of Yü and books of Hsia either transcribed, or referred to. 2 This passage from the 'Canon of Yao,' which we have already had in the first chapter of the Historical Records, appears later in the transcript from the 'Yi and Chi.' 1 Parts of the 'Canon of Shun' (para. 12 and 17) are again quoted here. 2 The first paragraph of the 'Tribute of Yü' (L. C. III. p. 92) is here quoted. 1 In the 'Works of Mencius' (L. C. II. p. 127) the passage reads, "Yü was eight years away from his home, and though he thrice passed the door of it he did not enter." 2 These passages appear in the transcript from 'Yi and Chi' below. 3 We have now the rest of the Yü Kung (Tribute of Yü) transcribed in its entirety. Dr. Legge in the notes to his translation of this book says very rightly, "The name, the tribute of Yü, gives a very insufficient account of the contents. The determination of the revenue, and of the various articles of tribute was, indeed, very important, but the book describes generally the labours of Yü in remedying the disasters occasioned by the overflowing waters?" It seems indeed to be just a description of the mountains and rivers of the several provinces of China. Of course no one, not even the great Yü, could have performed the Herculean task he is by some credited with doing. Dr. Legge, in fact, says with regard to the second part of the book (p. 129), "we cannot suppose that Yü travelled again along the hills or the rivers, for in that case his toil would have been endless." 1 The bird barbarians are said to refer to a people living in the north-east who ate the flesh of birds and beasts, and wore their skins. A commentator says that these were the Mohos or Sushêns, i.e. the Tungusic ancestors of the Manchus, who lived on the eastern seabord, north of the Ever White mountains. Their birds, beasts, trees, and all were white. They dwelt in the forests, but the country was so cold that they frequently inhabited deep holes in the ground. They kept pigs, ate pork, wore pigskins, and smeared themselves with lard several inches thick to keep off the winter's cold, were very dirty in their habits, but good archers, shooting with a bow four feet long, and using arrows 1 ft. 8 in. long tipped with stone. At their funerals they piled hundreds of dead pigs on their coffins to serve as food for the deceased. The wooden coffin was bound with cords, and on the top, which protruded from the ground, they poured a libation of wine until the cords rotted. 1 This hill seems to be called subsequently 'Bird-and-rat-in-the-same-hole' hill. 1 K‘ung-an-ku states that the six treasuries of nature were water, fire, metal, wood, earth, and grain. 1 Most of the 'Counsels of Kaoyao' is here transcribed, a few sentences near the close only being omitted. The historian never intimates in any of his extracts that he is drawing largely from the Book of History. 1 Here follows nearly the whole of the 'Yi and Chi' chapter of the Book of History. 1 This passage is found in Mencius (Bk. V. pt. 1, vi.), where, however, the name of Shun's son is not mentioned. There are, too, some discrepancies. Mencius has it that after Yi had been "presented to Heaven by Yü, seven
p. 106
years elapsed, when Yü died"; also that "after the three years' mourning had expired, Yi withdrew from the son of Yü to the north of Mount Chi." This word, which is also applied to the founder of the Chow dynasty, is the name of the seventh asterism (γ, δ, ε, and β in Sagittarius), so called from its resemblance to a chi (winnowing tray or basket). We find it here as the name of a hill, and it was also that of a marquisate. 1 Here follows a transcript of the whole of the 'Speech at Kan.' Dr. Legge observes in the concluding note to his translation of the chapter that the account is a clumsy imitation of Yü's expedition against the Sanmiao tribes in the 'Counsels of the Great Yü,' but there are so many imitations and repetitions in the Records that one soon tires of noticing them, and can but suppose that the historian's inventive faculty was faulty. 1 From the Preface to the Book of History, para. 7. 2 The 'Song of the Five Sons,' and the 'Punitive Expedition of Yin' are the names of two other short documents of the Shuching. The calendar getting into confusion is said to refer to a solar eclipse occurring in the fifth year of the reign of the Emperor Chungk‘ang or K‘ang the 2nd, which, according to the common scheme of chronology, was in the year B.C. 2166, but Professor De Lacouperie gives the rectified date as 1904, while it is 1948 B.C. in the Bamboo annals. The date of the eclipse cannot, however, be satisfactorily verified, and the doubts as to the antiquity of this part of Chinese history are therefore confirmed. 3 From the Preface to the Book of History, para. 8. 1 These characters, which mean 'pig-sty,' may be used derogatorily for the Shiwei ### tribes, which were to the east, west, north, and south of Turphan. One of the eighteen tribes joining Yelutache in 1125 A.D. was called the Great Yellow Shiwei (see Situation de Holin en Tartarie. T‘oungpao, vol. iv. p. 76). In Plath's Mandchurie, p. 80, we find that 'the Shiwei lived to the north of the Amur and of the Moho, and 3000 li from the Khitan country. You cross the river Cho, pass the mountain Toutsu, which
p. 109
is 3000 li in circumference, reach the Kioli river, and then come to the land of the Shiwei.' One of the most southerly branches of this stock were the Khitans, who came originally from the north of Liaotung (cf. Parker's History of the Wuhwan Tunguses, China Review, vol. xx. p. 100). 1 Li or Chieh Kuei is the 17th and last emperor of the Hsia dynasty, which the 'General Mirror of History' shows us lasted 439 years, but with the exception of K‘ungchia and the last emperor, where some few details of character are given, our historian merely gives the names of the last fourteen without any record of events or length of reigns whatever. This is the more surprising when, according to Dr. Legge, "the documents of the Shuching which follow the Tribute of Yü, commencing with the speech at Kan, delivered in B.C. 2197 by Yü's son and successor, may all be received as veritable monuments of antiquity, and are contemporaneous with the events which they relate." The meanings of the names of the emperors are worth noting, for it will then be seen how many are connected with astronomy or the calendar—a very pregnant fact. They are as follows:— Thus most of the names of the Emperors of this dynasty seem to be connected with astronomical or calendaric signs, and this fact will be more evident in the case of the names of the emperors in the succeeding dynasty of Shang.
Footnotes
(1) The great Yü or Hsia how. Kung yü and Hsia how were the names of two scholars contemporary with Ssŭma Ch‘ien. The characters used for writing Kung yü are the same as those for 'Tribute of Yü,' but reversed. (2) Ch‘i or Ch‘i ming = opening brightness, is the name for the planet Venus, so called because it 'opens the brightness' of the day (L. C. IV. 2, v. 9). (3) T‘aik‘ang, or K‘ang the 1st, literally 'great peace,' but ### is used for ### the second of the twenty-eight asterisms, answering to ι.κ.λ.μ. in Virgo constellation. (4) Chung K‘ang or K‘ang the 2nd. (5) Hsiang, the 'Counsellor,' is the name of a single red star, answering to seventy-three of Flamsteed between δ and ε of the Great Bear (Schlegel, p. 528). The interregnum of forty years during this reign referred to in different schemes of chronology is not referred to by our historian. (6) Shao K‘ang = K‘ang the lesser, or K‘ang the 3rd. (7) There seems an uncertainty as to the right character to be used for the Emperor Chu's name. Ssŭma gives first ###, which means the space between the throne and the Emperor's retiring room behind it, and then ### which means 'I.' The 'General Mirror of History' gives ###, which means a shuttle. It is likely that ###, which means a lance, and the star β in Böotes, is the one which should be used.
p. 110
(8) Huai = the Sophora Japonica tree; also the essence of the asterism ### tumulus composed of α in Equuleus and β in Aquarius. (9) Mang = bearded grain, a solar term falling about the 6th June. (10) Hsieh = ooze out. Read 'I' = a tributary of the Huai river. (11) Pu-hsiang = no surrender. Hsiang lou (###) is a star in Aries. (12) Chiung = a door-bar. (13) Chin = a hovel. (14) K‘ung chia = Cave A. Chia is a cyclical character, and the first of 'Ten stems,' and being used in notation may be said to be equal to 1, or A. (15) Kao or Hao = vast, glorious. Great Hao is the name for the first moon, as Small Hao is for the ninth moon. (16) Fa = to shoot; spring. (17) Li Kuei, or Chieh Kuei. Li = a shoe, and Chieh = cruel. Kuei is the last of the 'Ten stems' and therefore equivalent to the letter 10 or J.